I thought this film was excellent, a truly touching story with incredible performances and approporately moody cinematography.
Based on the novel by Jodi Picoult, 'My Sister's Keeper' tells the story of an 11-year-old girl who sues her parents for "medical emancipation" and the right not to donate a kidney to her sister, Kate, who is terminally ill with cancer. Abigail Breslin (Little Miss Sunshine) gives a very convincing and subtle performance which drives the emotional weight of the film. Her dying sister, played by Sofia Vassilieva, although not as demanding a role, is equally as convincing and along with Cameron Diaz, Joan Cusack and Alec Baldwin creates a film with uniquely powerful performances.
The gritty cinematography shows the landscapes of southern California in a different light, we truly feel for all the characters involved. One scene in particular, where, knowing that their daughter will die in a few days, Kate's parents grant her the wish of taking her to the beach. Watching her brother, sister and father play catch from under a blanket on the sand, Kate accepts and becomes at peace with her fate. This scene is a pivotal moment for Cameron Diaz's character as she accepts the inevetable and decides the spend some quality time in the last moments of Kate's life.
I found that, although and uncomfortable experience, it was a worthwhile one, a compresensive guide to evoking emotion in an audience.
It's always interesting to find someone prepared to go against the conventional wisdom about a film. The general perception is that this is a shameless tearjerker, a glorified movie of the week. I'm inclined to agree but my main concern was about the complete artificiality of the situation - the husband of the family is a fireman yet they have a movie star lifestyle and can afford medical treatment that must have cost a king's ransom - and it's complete avoidance of any moral dimension.
ReplyDelete